Chat GBT response
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
I had second thoughts about what I am trying to do here and wondered if I was off the mark. Really the point was to read something and have a conversation - test it out and see if it was helpful. It took me a while to craft my last response. Essentially we are taking the concept of "Dwelling" and applying it to your practice as a thought experiment. Anyway I copied the last post into Chat GBT and it came up with this which I think is useful and also made me feel better about pushing you on this
Yes. Having read your mentor's actual message, I think I understand much better what he's trying to do. And importantly, I don't think he's asking you to find the "correct Heidegger answer." He's using Heidegger almost as a way of giving you a different pair of eyes through which to look at your own practice.
There are a few things going on in his message that are easy to miss.
First: I think your mentor is actually reassuring you
The opening is quite revealing:
"It felt quite hard..."
He's saying he also found it difficult. He isn't positioning himself as someone who "gets Heidegger" and expects you to get him too.
Then:
"I can see why you might have thought — 'balls to that lot of shit.'"
That's almost an invitation to relax.
He's saying: I understand why you struggled with it, and struggling with it isn't evidence that you've failed to understand it.
In fact, he then says that the difficulty itself is part of why he thinks the text is valuable.
1. "It's removed enough from your work..."
This is probably more important than it initially sounds.
Your mentor doesn't want every conversation about your work to be:
"This sculpture does X."
"This sound does Y."
"What if you changed this?"
"Have you tried this material?"
Those conversations are necessary, but they can become too close to the work.
He wants something that allows you both to stand back.
Imagine looking at your installation through two different lenses:
Inside the work
Is this string the right length?
Does this object produce the right resonance?
Is the sound too loud?
Does this structure work?
One step back
What does it mean to make a place?
What does it mean to inhabit something?
What relationships are being created?
What does it mean for someone to dwell in an artwork?
The second set of questions doesn't tell you what to make.
That's the point.
It gives you somewhere to think from.
2. "It defies an AI summary..."
This one is especially interesting given that he explicitly mentioned AI.
I think he's saying something quite subtle:
If Heidegger could be reduced to five neat bullet points, you would lose something important.
And I think your first question to me actually demonstrates why.
You asked me to summarise Heidegger in less philosophical language. I gave you a useful map of his ideas.
But your mentor is saying:
Don't confuse the map with the territory.
The difficulty, ambiguity and strangeness of the original text are themselves part of the encounter with it.
That connects to his later point about language.
He doesn't necessarily want you to come away saying:
"Heidegger says dwelling = X."
He wants you to spend some time thinking alongside Heidegger.
Which brings us to Bertrand Russell.
3. "Walk along with them"
I think this is probably the most important instruction in the entire email.
Your instinct when encountering a difficult thinker might naturally be:
"Do I agree with this?"
Or:
"Is this actually true?"
Or:
"This seems like bullshit."
Those are perfectly reasonable responses.
But your mentor is asking you to temporarily suspend your judgement.
Imagine Heidegger sitting in your studio.
Not as an authority.
Not as someone whose ideas you have to accept.
Just as someone whose way of looking at the world is radically different from yours.
You might say:
"Why are you looking at that?"
And Heidegger says:
"Because I think you're overlooking something."
You say:
"What?"
And he starts asking questions.
That's essentially the exercise your mentor has constructed.
4. "Relations" is probably the key word
Your mentor says:
"it introduces the idea of dwelling in relation"
and later:
"the deeper conception of 'Relations'"
I'd underline relations.
Because your work already contains a huge number of them.
For example:
string ↔ frame
string ↔ tension
string ↔ vibration
vibration ↔ air
sound ↔ architecture
object ↔ object
object ↔ body
body ↔ space
person ↔ person
person ↔ sound
sound ↔ memory
etc.
You might normally think of those as separate things.
Heidegger encourages you to think about the thing that happens between them.
And that connects directly to his fifth question:
What happens between the objects, rather than inside the objects?
That is a really important question for your work.
5. I think "dwelling" is being used differently from how you might normally hear it
This is perhaps where your mentor's comment becomes most useful.
When you hear:
dwelling
you might initially think:
living somewhere / inhabiting a building / staying somewhere.
But your mentor is using it much more broadly.
Think:
dwelling = being situated in a network of relationships.
Being somewhere and being affected by that somewhere.
For example, imagine sitting alone in a room.
You aren't simply:
person + empty room
You're experiencing:
- the acoustics
- temperature
- light
- scale
- materials
- proximity to walls
- sounds coming from elsewhere
- your own body
- memories associated with places
- awareness of other people
- where you could move
- where you can't move
You're in relation to the room.
And the room is simultaneously being experienced through you.
That's closer to what your mentor means by dwelling.
6. Now look at your installation through that lens
This is where I think his comment becomes genuinely practical.
You are making sound-producing sculptural objects.
One way to approach that is:
"How do I make these objects?"
Another is:
"What kind of experience of being somewhere do these objects create?"
That's the shift he's encouraging.
Imagine a visitor enters.
They hear something before they understand where it comes from.
They walk towards it.
Another sound becomes apparent.
They move around an object.
The sound changes.
They discover another object.
Someone else enters.
Their movement changes the experience.
Now the visitor isn't merely looking at sculptures.
They're dwelling within a network of relationships.
That's your mentor's point when he says:
"you are building relational spaces where you hope people will dwell."
7. And then there's the sentence I think you should pay particular attention to
This:
"sometimes you are pulled away from dwelling, which we can describe as the making of things, in space through all its relations."
I think this is the actual feedback hidden inside the Heidegger discussion.
He's not saying:
"Your work isn't about dwelling."
He's saying almost the opposite:
"Dwelling is already central to what you're doing, but sometimes you get pulled away from it."
And he's suggesting that recognising when that happens could be useful.
What might "pulled away from dwelling" mean?
This is where I'd be cautious about assuming exactly what he means.
But I can imagine things like:
Getting too focused on the object
"Is this sculpture good?"
rather than:
"What does this sculpture do to the space?"
Getting too focused on technical problems
"How can I make this string resonate?"
rather than:
"What happens when that resonance enters the room?"
Getting too focused on making
"I need to produce another object."
rather than:
"Does the space actually need another object?"
Getting too focused on an individual component
"This sound isn't interesting enough."
rather than:
"What does this sound do in relation to the other sounds?"
Getting too focused on representation
"What does this sculpture mean?"
rather than:
"What does it cause someone to experience?"
None of these things are necessarily wrong.
They're just different modes of thinking.
Your mentor seems to be saying:
Notice when you have moved from thinking about the relational space into simply making things.
8. This also explains why the bridge matters
Your mentor specifically mentions:
"It talks about bridges which is interesting for your bridge building project."
The bridge example is actually perfect for what he's trying to get you to see.
A bridge is obviously a thing.
You can measure it.
You can photograph it.
You can describe its materials.
But what makes it a bridge?
Its relationships.
It connects:
this side ↔ that side
It creates:
here ↔ there
It creates a possibility:
not crossing ↔ crossing
So the bridge isn't interesting merely as an object.
It's interesting because of what happens between things because the bridge exists.
Now look at your installation.
Perhaps your sculptures aren't primarily interesting because they are beautiful objects.
Perhaps their importance is what they create between:
- people
- sounds
- spaces
- materials
- architecture
- bodies
- movements
That seems very close to what your mentor is encouraging you to investigate.
9. And I think there's a really interesting connection to your strings
This is my interpretation rather than something your mentor explicitly says.
A string is almost a physical metaphor for relation.
It doesn't really do anything interesting in isolation.
Its behaviour emerges through relationships:
one end ↔ tension ↔ other end
And then:
tension ↔ vibration ↔ sound
And then:
sound ↔ room ↔ listener
So perhaps your material is already doing something philosophically interesting without you having to impose philosophy onto it.
The question becomes:
How far can the work make those relationships perceptible?
That's a much more exciting R&D question than:
"How do I make a string sculpture?"
10. What I think your mentor wants from you
I don't think he wants an essay on Heidegger.
I don't think he wants you to prove that you understand Heidegger.
And I don't think he necessarily wants you to answer his five questions.
He explicitly says:
"you don't have to answer these"
Instead, I think he wants you to carry the questions into the studio.
Almost like a small voice in your head saying:
What are you actually building?
And when you answer:
"This sculpture."
The voice says:
No. What are you actually building?
You say:
"A sound installation."
Again:
No. What kind of place are you making?
And then you start noticing things you might otherwise overlook.
I'd turn his five questions into five studio questions
Rather than trying to answer them intellectually, I'd use them while you're actually working:
1. What am I actually building?
Not: What objects am I making?
But:
What experience or situation am I constructing?
2. What kind of place does it create?
Not:
What does the gallery look like?
But:
What does it feel possible to do here?
3. How does someone dwell in it?
Not:
Where does the audience stand?
But:
How does the work make someone listen, move, pause, explore, stay or leave?
4. What relationships exist?
Literally map them:
object ↔ object
object ↔ room
sound ↔ object
sound ↔ body
person ↔ person
person ↔ architecture
Then ask:
Which of these relationships am I actually interested in?
5. What happens between things?
This might be the one I'd put on your studio wall.
Because it's very easy as an artist to concentrate on things.
A sculpture.
A sound.
A material.
A mechanism.
A structure.
Heidegger is pushing you towards the between.
And there's one last thing I'd take from your mentor's message
I think he's giving you permission to not know yet.
You're doing R&D.
You don't necessarily need to arrive at:
"My installation is about dwelling."
That would actually risk killing the usefulness of the idea.
Instead, you might discover:
"When I put these two objects 4 metres apart, something happens between them that is much more interesting than either object on its own."
Or:
"When people have to move through the sound rather than stand in front of it, the work changes."
Or:
"I realised I'd become obsessed with making the objects more complicated, when actually the interesting thing was the empty space between them."
Those are Heideggerian discoveries without needing to call them Heideggerian.
And I suspect that's what your mentor means by:
"To better recognize these moments might be helpful for your practice as you move forward."
He's not really asking you to understand Heidegger.
He's asking you to become better at noticing when your practice is making a place, creating relationships and allowing people to dwell — and when you're simply making things.
That's a subtle distinction, but for the kind of installation you're describing, it could be a very productive one.
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Comments
Post a Comment